Why – The final question?

One of my favourite Roger Whittaker songs is ‘Why’. Written fifty years ago, Whittaker asks about climate change, lost love, regret… universal questions of why things happen as they do:

Will the grass be gone from underneath the sky
Will the golden flower wither soon and die
Will the fire burn out the land
And the sea fill-up with sand
Will the last word ever spoken be why?

Yesterday morning at Men’s Shed we enjoyed a robust discussion. War in the Middle East inevitably led to religion… Why can’t Jews, Christians and Muslims live together peacefully? Why do we need religion?

One gent had served in the military in Northern Ireland. We discussed Irish history, the ‘why?’ of conflict, whether peace is possible. After suggested easy answers to difficult questions, the final question seemed to be ‘Why?’.

I came home to news about our disappearing fish. In response to my pond-emptying news a friend directed me to a ‘Pakefield Community’ Facebook page. Other local ponds have been emptied of fish too!

After various thoughts and speculation… heron, foxes, herring gulls… the consensus – backed with photographic evidence – is that there’s an otter visiting our gardens.

But why an otter in Pakefield?

The evening news reported on the annual Cooper’s Hill Cheese-Rolling. This tradition, believed to be over six hundred years old, requires participants to race down a steep, 200-yard hill chasing a 7–9-pound wheel of Double Gloucester cheese.

The first person over the finish line a wins the cheese. Multiple races are held during the day; there are often multiple injuries. British bonkersness at its best. But why?

Jesus’ last question was a ‘Why?’ question. Just before he died he cries: ‘My God, My God, why have you forsaken me?’

I know that the Christian hope is of a new heaven and a new earth. ‘There will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain’. The question ‘Why?’ will be irrelevant.

In the meantime ‘why?’ is often the final question.

8 thoughts on “Why – The final question?

  1. Wow… cheese chasing… that’s definitely a new one for me! I’m amused and glad you shared.

    That question asked by Jesus… it’s equivocal to someone of Catholic tradition saying “I said the Our Father”.

    When Jesus quoted that little bit from Psalm 22, it would’ve immediately brought to mind the entire rest of the passage for any “good person” of the day. There’s so much rich, deep, meaning in Christ’s words, and the words He was echoing. It was not that God had actually forsaken Christ, but rather Christ’s way of, while naked and dying on a cross, with a crown of thorns on his head and “King of the Jews” inscribed for him, declaring a greater work, being done by a greater King!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to David Cancel reply